Which social platform should a business start with?

Plenty of owners have a Facebook page from the year they opened, an Instagram account someone set up for them, a TikTok they meant to try and a LinkedIn profile with an old job title on it. Each one got a burst of posts at the start and then went quiet, because the actual work of the business came first. A customer who lands on one of those accounts sees a last post from months back and wonders whether you are still open. If you have been asking yourself what the best social media platform for business owners like you is, the useful answer is usually one platform posted to steadily, with a second added later once the first has become a habit.

Spreading thin is the most common problem we see. Posting once in a while on four platforms tends to show less than posting every week on one, because each audience only ever sees the gaps. The good news is that the choice can be made this week, using things you already know about your customers and your own calendar.

Start where your customers already ask questions

Before thinking about which app is popular, look at where people already talk to you or about you. Set aside part of an afternoon and go through these:

• Open the message inbox on your Facebook page and on Instagram and scroll back over the past few months. Count the real questions on each, such as prices, availability or whether you cover a certain area.
• Look at the questions and reviews on your Google Business Profile, because those people were searching for you directly.
• Search for your trade and your town in the local community groups. In our experience, a lot of Greater Manchester recommendations happen in neighborhood Facebook groups, and in South Florida the neighborhood Facebook groups and Nextdoor carry plenty of posts asking who people use for a job.
• Ask your next few new customers how they found you, and write the answers down somewhere you will keep them.

Good looks like one platform clearly turning up more often than the others. That is your first platform. If nothing turns up anywhere, pick the one your best customers use in their own lives. For homeowners booking repairs or services, that is often Facebook, and for buyers of services where looks matter (hair, nails, interiors, food), it is often Instagram.

Keep your Google Business Profile in the picture whatever you choose. It sits outside social media, but it is where many local customers check you before they call, so a current photo and correct hours there are worth more than another new account.

Finding the best social media platform for business work like yours

The second check is what your work looks like on a phone screen. Some businesses have something new to show every week, and others have very little that photographs well. Roughly, work falls into one of these groups:

• Before and after work, such as remodels, landscaping, car detailing, pool cleaning or hair. This photographs well, and both Instagram and Facebook handle it nicely.
• Work where the process is the interesting part, such as baking, a mechanic finding a fault or a tradesperson fitting something tricky. This suits short video on Instagram, TikTok or YouTube Shorts.
• Advice and expertise, such as accounting, legal work or supplying other businesses. Written posts on LinkedIn or Facebook usually carry this better than pictures.
• Work that is private or slow to show, such as cleaning inside clients' homes or care services. Here, helpful tips and real reviews do most of the lifting.

A quick test: open your phone and look at the photos you took at work over the last month. If you find a handful you would be happy for a customer to see, you have a photo business, and posting will feel manageable. If the interesting part is watching the job happen, you have a video business, and that asks more of your time, so factor it into the next step.

Whatever you post, use real photos of real jobs. Customers notice when pictures look too polished, and images made with AI tools should never be presented as your own work.

Be honest about the hours you have each week

Write down the time you can protect on a normal week, then cut it in half, because the busy weeks are the ones where posting stops. Plan for that smaller amount.

A photo post with a short, plain caption usually takes well under an hour once the photo exists. A short video takes longer, especially the first several, while you get used to filming and adding captions. Replying to comments and messages also takes time, and it is the part customers notice most, so leave room for it.

If you have an hour or two a week, that is one platform, a couple of posts and replies within a day. If you have more, and the first platform has felt easy for a couple of months, add a second one that suits a different kind of content, for example Facebook for updates and reviews and Instagram for job photos.

Two habits make the hours go further. Take photos during the week as jobs finish, so you are never starting from nothing. Then pick one fixed slot, write the captions in one sitting and schedule the posts with the scheduling tool built into Facebook and Instagram, so they go out on their own while you work.

Park the other accounts so they still look cared for

Deleting an old account can lose your name on that platform and any reviews or followers it has, so in most cases it is better to park it. A parked account says clearly where you are active and still gives a stranger the right details. Here is what to do on each one:

• Update the profile photo and cover image so they match your main account.
• Rewrite the bio as one line about what you do and where, followed by a line saying where to find your updates and send messages, with the link to your main platform.
• Pin a post that says the same thing, so anyone who scrolls sees it first.
• Check that your phone number, hours and website are right, and turn on an automatic reply to messages that points people to where you answer.

Once a month, open each parked account, answer anything that came in and remove spam comments. While you are there, make sure the login email is one you still control and that two-step login is switched on, because abandoned accounts are the ones that tend to get taken over. If an account has no followers and has been empty for years, archiving or deleting it is fine.

How Pixedi handles this in Care + Social

In the Care + Social plan ($700 a month), we look at where your customers already reach you and choose one or two platforms with you, then post on them from a content plan written in your brand voice, with one revision per post. The accounts you are not using get parked the way described above, and because the plan includes everything in Care, we also watch your online accounts and check that your listings and reviews stay consistent. Each month you get one plain report on what we did and what changed, in numbers, and you never have to log in anywhere.

What to do this week

Open the inbox on each of your accounts, note how many real customer questions each one received over the past few months, and ask your next few customers where they found you. Pick the platform that comes out ahead and put its link into the bio of every other account. Then block one fixed slot in your calendar next week to post a real photo of a finished job and answer whatever is waiting in your messages.

Ask AI about this article

Opens the assistant in a new tab with this page as the source.

ChatGPTClaudePerplexityGemini